Perry a dialogue on personal identity and immortality. Perry s excellent dialogue makes a complicated topic stimulating and accessible without any sacrifice of scholarly accuracy or thoroughness. The four theories of personal identitybody theory, soul theory, memory theory, brain theory. In this paper, i offer an explication of john perrys arguments on pages 2730 of his dialogue on personal identity and immortality. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality for full. Best product a dialogue on personal identity and immortality john r. John perrys dialogue a first night in the first night weirob distinguishes between two ways in which we talk about identity. Personal identity personal identity can be broken down into three areas. In the first night of john perrys paper, a dialogue on personal identity and immortality, perry introduces us to gretchen weirob, a teacher of philosophy who was hospitalized due to injuries that she sustained from a motorcycle incident, and her longtime friend chaplain, sam miller. Perrys excellent dialogue makes a complicated topic stimulating and accessible without any.
To survive means that there would be someone for whom it would be appropriate for me to anticipate having their future experiences. Dialogue on consciousness by john perry overdrive rakuten. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett philosophical dialogues 9780915144532 by perry, john and a great selection of similar new, used and collectible books available now at great prices. Perrys dialogue on personal identity and immortality second night duration. John martin fischer, responsiveness and moral responsibility. Aug 14, 2019 best product a dialogue on personal identity and immortality john r.
It deals with standard problems in the theory of personal identity in the form of a dialogue between a terminally ill university professor at a small midwestern college, gretchen weirob, and her two friends, sam miller and dave cohen. Personal identity university of california press identity, personal identity and the self hackett publications knowledge, possibility and consciousness mit press dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett publications dialogue. Refer to the book called a dialogue on personal identity and. In this excerpt from the dialogue, the two primary characters, miller and weirob, engage in discussion dealing with the connection between memory, identity, and survival. Iohn perry 0 a dialogue on personal identity and immortality 387 a dialogue on personal identity and immortality m john perry john perry teaches philosophy at stanford university. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett. Refer to the book called a dialogue on personal identity and immortality by john perry.
In john perrys dialogue on personal identity and immortality, gretchen weirob rejects the cartesian theory of the self as the basis for immortality. I can remember only my own past thoughts and feelings, and you only yours. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality john perry. A dialogue on personal identity and confidentiality summary 1479 words 6 pages. Show me how it could even be so much as possible that i survive the death and destruction of my material body. Buy a dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett philosophical dialogues new ed by perry, john isbn. In john perry s a dialogue on personal identity and immortality these composing aspects of personal identity are discussed at length. In john perrys a dialogue on personal identity and immortality these composing aspects of personal identity are discussed at length.
In the first night of john perry s paper, a dialogue on personal identity and immortality, perry introduces us to gretchen weirob, a teacher of philosophy who was hospitalized due to injuries that she sustained from a motorcycle incident, and her longtime friend chaplain, sam miller. More than theorizing, this text expresses ways of defending ideas and proving them to be true or morelikelytobetrue than other ideas. Perrys dialogue on personal identity and immortality third. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality by john perry 1978 this is a record of conversations of gretchen weirob, a teacher of philosophy at a small midwestern college, and two of her friends. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett philosophical dialogues kindle edition by perry, john. The four theories of personal identity body theory, soul theory, memory theory, brain theory. View perrya dialogue on personal identity and immortality. John perry revisits the cast of characters of his classic a dialogue on personal identity and immortality in this absorbing dialogue on consciousness. Perrys dialogue on personal identity and immortality third night. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett philosophical dialogues john perry a dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett philosophical dialogues john perry perrys excellent dialogue makes a complicated topic stimulating and accessible without any sacrifice of scholarly accuracy or thoroughness. John perry 1943 dialogue on personal identity and immortality immortality to personal identity. Perry s dialogue on personal identity and immortality second night duration. Dialogue of personal identity and immortality 851 words.
Show me how it could even be so much as possible that. In john perrys a dialogue on personal identity and immortality, there is an indication of a conversation that existed between miller and weirob. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading a dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett philosophical dialogues. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Professionals will appreciate the works command of the issues and depth of argument, while students will find that it excites interest and imagination. Weirobs main objection to the idea that a person could survive herhis own death is that there is no god.
What makes the risen christ the very same person as the jesus who was crucified. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett philosophical dialogues john perry a dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett philosophical dialogues john perry perry s excellent dialogue makes a complicated topic stimulating and accessible without any sacrifice of scholarly accuracy or thoroughness. A person at one time is the very same person as a person at a. Perry s a dialogue on personal identity and immortality gives an example of logical thinking and argumentation. Show me how it could even be so much as possible that i survive the death and destruction of my material body definition of survival 397. This is a record of conversations of gretchen weirob, a teacher of philosophy at a small mid western college, and several of her friends. Perrys dialogue on personal identity and immortality first night. Cartesian dualism, property dualism, materialism, the problem of other minds. Philosophy final 1 gina calderone pt2 flashcards quizlet. It is implied that immortality is meaningless without personal identity, and therefore almost the entire argument is about personal identity really. Analysis of perrys theories of personal identity magnificat. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality by perry, john, 1943. In john perry s dialogue on personal identity and immortality, gretchen weirob rejects the cartesian theory of the self as the basis for immortality.
The following question refers to john perrys dialogue on personal identity and immortality. John perry argument reconstructiona dialogue on personal identity and immortality, p. Aug 25, 20 perry s dialogue on personal identity and immortality first night. Perrys 1978 book a dialogue on personal identity and immortality deals with standard problems in the theory of personal identity in the form of a dialogue between a mortally wounded university professor, gretchen weirob, and her two friends, sam miller and dave cohen. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality is a book by the philosopher john perry. Reviews of the dialogue on personal identity and immortality thus far in regards to the ebook we have dialogue on personal identity and immortality feedback people have never but eventually left their own report on the experience, you arent read it nevertheless.
Personal identity university of california press identity, personal identity and the self hackett publications knowledge, possibility and consciousness mit press dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett publications dialogue on good, evil and the existence of god hackett publications. Perrya dialogue on personal identity and immortality. In this delightful booklet john perry, a philosophy professor at stanford, discusses personal identity and immortality. Buy a cheap copy of a dialogue on personal identity and. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality by john perry and publisher hackett publishing company, inc save up to 80% by choosing the etextbook option for isbn. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality wikipedia. Perrys a dialogue on personal identity and immortality gives an example of logical thinking and argumentation. View perry a dialogue on personal identity and immortality. Description of the book dialogue on personal identity and immortality. I assign john perrys dialogue on personal identity and immortality for a. John perry, a dialogue on personal identity and immortality. What is humes critique of the metaphysical argument of an immortal soul. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality by john perry.
Discussion leads to three candidates for personal identity. Aug 31, 20 perry s dialogue on personal identity and immortality third night. The conversations took place in her hospital room on the three nights before she died from injuries sustained in a motorcycle accident. Perrys excellent dialogue makes a complicated topic stimulating and accessible without any sacrifice of scholarly accuracy or thoroughness. Why does weirob think that on the view of a person that miller introduces at the beginning of the second. The immortality of the soul and personal identity able to clarify the issues of an identical self that continuously thrives even after a persons death. A person at one time is the very same person as a person at a later time if and only if they have the very same immaterial soulvery same immaterial soul. Pdf a dialogue on personal identity and immortality. John perryauthor of the acclaimed dialogue on personal identity and immortality hackett publishing co.
In the early part of the work, gretchen and her friends consider whether evil provides a problem for those who believe in the. The question of personal identity is a question of the conditions of the numerical identity of persons, i. Perrys dialogue on personal identity and immortality first. Best product a dialogue on personal identity and immortality.
1404 1499 1316 808 1188 1493 174 616 482 899 78 235 111 1288 340 554 299 72 1064 225 1174 845 1324 283 739 382 804 542 280 582 528 1281 49 389